Just finished reading this article on "Rich Preachers in Brazil." As in the U.S., one must notice the dys-synchrony of the work "Rich" and the word "Preacher." These five have net worths of millions of dollars and the top earner has been jailed for "charlatanism" and other allegations are outstanding. The popularity of these preachers is two-fold: 1. They have charismatic personalities; 2. They preach "Prosperity Theology.
Charismatic personalities lead to success in many fields but also can hide faults and false motives from others. In the field of Medicine, for example, some of the worst doctors have thriving practices and patients who worship them, but are acknowledged by their peers to practice sub-par medicine and to use excessive and often unnecessary testing and ill-advised surgery. The peers keep quiet save for talk among themselves for fear of liability issues. Hospitals hesitate to keep them off the staff or to remove them for the same reasons. It is a surmountable task to assimilate the data needed to successfully mount a successful action. In some cases it is not until the insurance companies raise questions of utilization data or malpractice claims that action is forthcoming.
The moral: "All that glitters is not old," and personality can hide many faults and false motives. The "call" to preaching is not a call to riches but to service to God and one's fellow man. While these preachers hoard the millions of dollars, build ostentatious church structures, clothe themselves in fine clothing, and eat "high on the hog," there are millions of citizens without sufficient resources to maintain the lowest hierarchy of human needs, food, shelter, clothing (See Maslow "Hierarchy of Needs"). While these preachers may allow some of their fortunes to be used for good purpose, they keep more than the "sower's share" for themselves. If indeed you are serving God, then keeping what is God's, and rationalizing it by preaching a false doctrine, is sinful. Much less, living in a style comparable to Caesar is certainly the antithesis of living in fellowship with God and with your fellow man.
Whether the preacher is part of a conventional and mainline religion, e.g. Protestant, Catholic, Muslim, where oversight and accountability is formal and structured, he must be accountable to God. Since there are roughly 30,000 different denominations of Protestantism, for example, most are non-denominational and accountable only to themselves and their cronies, who's minding the store? While false prophets receive their judgment at the end of times, one must ask just what is our responsibility to protect the innocent seeking a Holy path from the charlatans of these churchs?
Pray!
Robert L. Baldwin, M.D.